Best Electric Fence for Dogs

Keeping your dog safe while giving them room to roam can be challenging, but the right electric dog fence makes it easier. Whether you need a wireless dog fence, an in-ground system, or a GPS dog fence, these solutions help create a secure boundary without the need for a traditional physical fence.

Modern electric fences, like the PetSafe Wireless Dog Fence, Halo Collar, and SpotOn GPS Dog Fence, offer advanced features such as GPS tracking, real-time alerts, rechargeable collars, and customizable boundaries. They’re designed for different needs, from small yards to large properties, and can work for all dogs—including stubborn dogs that need extra training support.

In this guide, we’ll compare the best electric dog fences, highlight key features like battery life, correction levels, and ease of setup, and provide tips for dog training. Whether you're looking for a simple pet fence system or a high-tech GPS wireless dog fence, you’ll find the right option to keep your dog safe and give you peace of mind.

Understanding Electric Dog Fence Systems

Electric dog fences are designed to keep your pet safely contained within a designated area without the need for a traditional physical fence. These systems use either wireless signals, GPS tracking, or buried wire to establish a fence boundary, and they communicate with a dog collar receiver to alert your pet when they approach the edge of the boundary. Depending on the system, the collar may issue a beep, vibration, or static correction to reinforce the boundary and aid in dog training.

Types of Electric Dog Fences

There are three main types of dog fence systems, each system has its own benefits depending on your yard size, dog breed, and training needs.

1. Wireless Dog Fence

• Uses a circular boundary created by a transmitter.
• Easy to install with no need for buried wire or fence posts.
• Best for flat, open areas with minimal obstructions.
• Popular models: PetSafe Wireless Dog Fence, SportDOG Wireless, and PetSafe Stay & Play.

2. In-Ground Dog Fence Systems

• Requires buried wire to create a custom fence boundary.
• Works well for irregularly shaped yards or properties with obstacles.
• More reliable than wireless systems, especially for stubborn dogs.
• Popular models: PetSafe In-Ground Fence, SportDOG In-Ground System, and Extreme Dog Fence Kit.

3. GPS Wireless Dog Fence

• Uses GPS signal instead of buried wire or a stationary transmitter.
• Offers real-time GPS tracking and highly customizable boundaries.
• Ideal for large properties or owners who need flexibility.
• Popular models: Halo Collar, SpotOn GPS Dog Fence, and Fi Smart Collar.

Best Electric Dog Fences

Choosing the right electric dog fence depends on your property size, your dog’s temperament, and whether you prefer a wireless, in-ground, or GPS-based system. Here are some of the best options in each category, considering factors like battery life, correction levels, waterproof collars, and ease of setup.

Best Wireless Dog Fences

Wireless dog fences are easy to install and use a circular boundary created by a central transmitter. These systems are best for flat, open areas and provide a simple, no-fuss containment solution.

1. PetSafe Wireless Dog Fence – Best Overall

• Covers up to ½ acre with an adjustable circular boundary.
• No buried wire required for easy installation.
• Waterproof, rechargeable e-collar with five static correction levels plus a beep mode.
• Suitable for dogs over 5 pounds.

Drawbacks:

• Circular boundary limits customization.
• Not ideal for properties with obstacles or steep slopes.

2. PetSafe Stay & Play Wireless Fence – Best for Portability

• Covers up to ¾ acre with a portable, easy-to-set-up transmitter.
• Adjustable correction levels, including tone-only mode.
• Works with multiple dogs using additional collars.

Drawbacks:

• The circular range may not suit all properties.
• Some dogs may require extra training to adjust.

3. SportDOG Wireless Fence – Best for Stubborn Dogs

• Covers up to 1½ acres with an adjustable boundary.
• Stronger static correction settings for larger, more stubborn dogs.
• Waterproof, long-lasting battery life in the collar receiver.

Drawbacks:

• Larger, bulkier fence collar compared to PetSafe models.
• More expensive than standard wireless fences.

Best In-Ground Dog Fence Systems

For a more customizable fence boundary, in-ground fences use buried wire to create a specific containment area. These systems offer greater reliability and work well for irregularly shaped yards.

4. PetSafe In-Ground Fence – Best for Customization

• Covers up to 10 acres with additional wire.
• Customizable boundaries for uniquely shaped properties.
• Adjustable correction levels, including tone and vibration modes.

Drawbacks:

• Requires time-consuming buried wire installation.
• May not be ideal for renters or those needing a portable option.

5. eXtreme Dog Fence Kit – Best for Durability

• Heavy-duty buried wire resists weather damage and wear.
• Supports multiple dogs with additional fence collars.
• Waterproof, long battery life, and customizable settings.

Drawbacks:

• Requires manual fence posts and trenching for wire installation.
• More expensive upfront but durable long-term.

6. SportDOG In-Ground Fence – Best for Large Dogs

• Covers up to 100 acres with additional wire.
• Stronger static correction settings for stubborn dogs.
• Durable, waterproof collar built for rough terrain.

Drawbacks:

• Initial setup takes longer due to buried wire installation.
• The collar may be too bulky for small dogs.

Best GPS Wireless Dog Fences

For large properties or open spaces, GPS dog fences provide real-time tracking and eliminate the need for fence posts or buried wire. These systems are ideal for dog owners who want flexibility and advanced features.

7. Halo Collar 2+ – Best Smart GPS Fence

• Uses GPS tracking to create custom virtual fences.
• Works with Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and real-time GPS signals.
• Doubles as a training collar with tone, vibration, and static correction.
• Mobile app integration for easy adjustments.

Drawbacks:

• More expensive than traditional fences.
• Requires a monthly subscription for full GPS tracking features.

8. SpotOn GPS Dog Fence – Most Accurate GPS Fence

• No buried wire or transmitter required—sets up with GPS tracking.
• Customizable fence boundary for any property size.
• Waterproof, rechargeable collar with long battery life.

Drawbacks:

• High price point compared to other containment systems.
• May not be as precise in areas with weak GPS signals.

9. Garmin Alpha 200i GPS Fence – Best for Working Dogs

• Combines GPS tracking with training collar functions.
• Real-time location tracking with detailed mapping features.
• Suitable for hunting dogs, working dogs, and large properties.

Drawbacks:

• Complex setup requiring time to configure.
• Expensive compared to standard pet containment systems

Where to Buy Electric Dog Fences and Purchase Tips

Once you've decided on the best electric dog fence for your pet, the next step is finding the right place to buy it. Choosing a reputable retailer ensures you get a high-quality product, a valid warranty, and reliable customer service. If you’re ready to make a purchase, check Amazon, Chewy, and manufacturer websites for the latest discounts and promotions. Before clicking “checkout,” or buying from any store, consider these key factors to get the best dog fence system for your needs:

• Read Customer Reviews – Look for verified buyers' feedback on battery life, signal reliability, and ease of installation.
• Check Warranty & Return Policies – Brands like PetSafe and SportDOG offer manufacturer warranties, which are essential for long-term support.
• Compare Prices Across Retailers – Amazon may have discounts, while Chewy or manufacturer websites may offer bundle deals.
• Look for Seasonal Sales – Major discounts are available during Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and Prime Day.
• Check for Bundled Accessories – Some fences include extra fence collars, training flags, or extra wire at no additional cost.
• Consider Subscription Costs (For GPS Fences) – Models like Halo Collar and SpotOn GPS Dog Fence may require monthly fees for real-time tracking.

Key Features to Consider When Choosing an Electric Dog Fence

Selecting the right dog fence system depends on factors like coverage area, fence type, battery life, and durability. Some of the key features to consider when choosing electric fence are:

1. Types of Electric Dog Fences

There are three main types of electric dog fences, each with unique advantages and limitations:

• Wireless Dog Fence – Ideal for small to medium yards with minimal obstructions. Quick to set up but limited to a circular boundary.
• In-Ground Dog Fence – Requires buried wire but offers customizable fence boundaries, making it great for irregularly shaped properties.
• GPS Wireless Dog Fence – Uses GPS tracking instead of a transmitter or buried wire. Best for large properties and open spaces but may require a subscription.

2. Coverage Area

Consider how much space you need to enclose. Wireless dog fences typically cover ½ to 1½ acres, while in-ground systems can be expanded up to 100 acres with additional wire. GPS dog fences offer virtually unlimited range but rely on GPS signal accuracy. If you have a large property or live in a rural area, an in-ground fence or GPS wireless system may be the best option.

3. Battery Life and Power Source

Consider whether the fence collar uses rechargeable or replaceable batteries. Rechargeable collars are more convenient and cost-effective over time, while replaceable battery collars may last longer between charges.

4. Waterproof and Durability Features

A waterproof shock collar is essential if your dog enjoys playing in the water or if you live in an area with frequent rain. Durable materials are also important for active or large dogs that may test the limits of their fence system.

5. Number of Dogs Supported

If you have multiple dogs, choose a dog fence system that allows for additional collar receivers. Many systems, like SportDOG and PetSafe, support multiple dogs with the purchase of extra collars.

6. Ease of Installation

Wireless dog fences are the easiest to set up, usually requiring only a base station and proper collar calibration. In-ground dog fences require more effort, including burying wire and installing fence posts. GPS-based systems require little to no setup but need strong real-time GPS tracking to function effectively.

7. Cost and Subscription Fees

Consider both upfront costs and any potential ongoing fees. In-ground and wireless pet containment systems have a one-time cost, while some GPS wireless dog fences, like SpotOn or Halo Collar, may require a monthly subscription for advanced features like real-time tracking.

How to Install and Set Up an Electric Dog Fence

Proper installation and setup of an electric dog fence are essential to ensuring your pet’s safety and effective containment. Following the right installation steps can prevent signal issues, improve reliability, and make dog training easier. Here is a detailed guide on how to set up each type of system.

Installing a Wireless Dog Fence

A wireless dog fence is one of the easiest systems to install because it doesn’t require digging or burying wires. The setup involves placing a central transmitter and adjusting the boundary settings. Here’s how to do it:

1. Choose a Central Location – Place the transmitter indoors, preferably in a dry area, at least 3 feet away from metal objects, appliances, and Wi-Fi routers to prevent interference.
2. Adjust the Boundary Range – Most wireless pet containment systems create a circular boundary that can be adjusted using the transmitter. Set the coverage area according to your needs.
3. Test the Signal – Before placing the dog collar on your pet, walk around the perimeter holding the collar receiver to ensure it beeps at the correct locations. Make adjustments if needed.
4. Fit the Collar on Your Dog – The waterproof collar should be snug but comfortable, with the contact points touching the skin to ensure effective static correction when necessary.
5. Start the Training Process – Begin with beep and vibration modes before introducing static correction if required. Walk your dog near the boundary to teach them where they can and cannot go.

Installing an In-Ground Dog Fence

An in-ground fence system is a more permanent solution that allows for customizable boundaries. While installation takes more time, it provides a more reliable containment system, especially for large dogs or stubborn dogs. Follow these steps for proper setup:

1. Plan Your Layout – Map out the area where you want the buried wire to run. Avoid obstacles like driveways, metal structures, and utility lines that could interfere with the signal.
2. Dig the Trench – Using a shovel or a trenching tool, dig a 1-3 inch deep trench along the planned boundary. If crossing a driveway or pathway, use a PVC conduit to protect the wire.
3. Lay and Bury the Wire – Carefully place the wire fence in the trench, ensuring there are no kinks or breaks. Cover it with soil, leaving small marker flags along the boundary to aid in training.
4. Connect the Transmitter – Plug the fence system transmitter into a power source and connect the wires. Some models, like SportDOG or PetSafe Stay & Play, allow for customizable correction levels.
5. Test the System – Walk along the boundary with the collar receiver to ensure the warning beep or vibration activates at the correct locations. Adjust the settings if needed.
6. Fit the Collar and Train Your Dog – Place the rechargeable collar on your pet and start with the lowest correction setting. Use the marker flags as a visual aid during training.

Setting Up a GPS Wireless Dog Fence

A GPS dog fence is the most advanced option, using satellite signals instead of physical fences. These systems, like the Halo Collar or SpotOn GPS Dog Fence, allow you to create virtual boundaries without the need for wires. Here’s how to set one up:

1. Download the Manufacturer’s App – Most GPS fences require an app to create and manage boundaries. Install the app and create an account.
2. Set Up the Fence Boundary – Walk the perimeter of the desired containment area while using the app to map out the boundary. Save the settings once completed.
3. Adjust the Correction Settings – GPS fences allow for customizable alerts, including beep, vibration, and static correction. Start with beep-only mode before adjusting as needed.
4. Fit the Collar on Your Dog – Make sure the collar receiver is secure and maintains a GPS signal at all times. Some models require a clear sky view to function properly.
5. Test the System – Walk around the boundary while monitoring the app to ensure the real-time GPS tracking is accurate.
6. Start Training – Like with other fences, begin with beep-only mode and gradually introduce static correction as needed. Use positive reinforcement to help your dog learn the boundaries.

Training Your Dog to Use an Electric Fence

Proper training is crucial for an electric dog fence to be effective. Most dogs need about two weeks to fully understand the system and respect the boundaries. To avoid accidents and properly train your dog, try to do the following:

1. Introduce Your Dog to the Boundary Flags – Walk your dog near the perimeter while using a leash. Let them see and sniff the pet fence marker flags while activating the warning beep.
2. Use Beep and Vibration Mode First – Start with only beep or vibration correction levels to teach your dog where the boundary is. Reward them with treats when they stay inside the safe zone.
3. Increase the Correction Level If Needed – For stubborn dogs, gradually introduce static correction at the lowest level to reinforce boundary training.
4. Practice Off-Leash Training Under Supervision – Once your dog shows understanding, let them roam off-leash while you monitor their response to the boundary alerts.
5. Remove Flags Gradually – After about two weeks, begin removing the boundary flags to help your dog adjust to the invisible barrier.

Common Installation Mistakes to Avoid

Many issues with dog containment systems arise from incorrect installation or setup. Some of the most common mistakes and how to avoid them are:

• Placing the Wireless Transmitter Near Metal Objects – Metal can interfere with the GPS signal or wireless dog fence system. Keep transmitters away from appliances and Wi-Fi routers.
• Not Testing the System Before Training – Always walk the boundary with the collar to ensure proper fence work before allowing your dog off-leash.
• Burying the Wire Too Deep in an In-Ground Fence – Wires should be placed 1-3 inches underground to maintain a strong signal.
• Skipping Training Sessions – Even the best invisible dog fence won’t work if your dog hasn’t been trained properly. Consistency is key.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do electronic dog fences really work?

Yes, when properly installed and used with consistent training, electronic dog fences are an effective way to keep dogs safely contained. They create an invisible boundary that sends a beep, vibration, or static correction when a dog gets too close, reinforcing where they can and cannot go. Success depends on proper training, collar fit, and correction level adjustments.

What is better than an invisible fence?

A physical fence is the most reliable option for containment, especially for dogs that are easily distracted or highly motivated to escape. However, for large properties or areas where a traditional fence isn’t practical, a GPS dog fence or a customizable in-ground fence system can be better alternatives to standard wireless fences.

Will an electric fence stop a dog?

For most dogs, electric fences provide an effective boundary when combined with proper training. However, highly determined or easily distracted dogs may ignore the static correction, especially if they see something exciting beyond the boundary. A physical fence or a combination of both may be necessary for these cases.

Is this electric fence system right for my pet?

The right dog fence system mainly depends on:

• Your yard size and layout (wireless fences work best in open areas, while in-ground fences allow custom shapes)
• Your dog’s behavior and temperament (stubborn dogs may need stronger correction levels)
• Your budget and preference for installation (in-ground fences require more setup, while GPS fences have higher costs)

If you’re unsure, a professional dog trainer or fence expert can help recommend the best option.

Conclusion

Finding the right electric dog fence is key to keeping your pet safe while giving them the freedom to roam. Whether you choose a wireless, in-ground, or GPS fence, the best option depends on your yard size, dog’s temperament, and training needs.

If you need an easy, portable solution, the PetSafe Wireless Fence is a great choice. For a more customizable boundary, an in-ground fence system like SportDOG works well. GPS fences like SpotOn are ideal for large properties, while the PetSafe Stubborn Dog Fence offers stronger correction for harder-to-train dogs.

Proper installation and training are crucial for success. A poorly installed system or lack of training can lead to inconsistent results. Take the time to set up your dog fence system correctly and introduce your pet to their new boundaries gradually.

If you're considering a physical fence or need help installing an in-ground dog fence, Ergeon offers professional fencing services. Our team can assist with expert installation and provide guidance on the best fencing solution for your property.